Archive Home arrow Reviews: arrow Video Cards arrow MSI R6870 Radeon HD 6870 Video Card
MSI R6870 Radeon HD 6870 Video Card E-mail
Reviews - Featured Reviews: Video Cards
Written by Bruce Normann   
Friday, 05 November 2010
Table of Contents: Page Index
MSI R6870 Radeon HD 6870 Video Card
AMD Radeon HD 6870 GPU Features
Closer Look: MSI R6870
MSI R6870 Detailed Features
Video Card Testing Methodology
DX10: 3DMark Vantage
DX10: Crysis
DX11: Aliens vs. Predator
DX11: Battlefield: Bad Company 2
DX11: DiRT-2 Demo
DX11: H.A.W.X. 2
DX11: Lost Planet 2
DX9 SSAO: Mafia II
DX11: Unigine Heaven 2.1
MSI R6870 Temperatures
VGA Power Consumption
AMD Radeon HD 6870 Final Thoughts
MSI R6870 Conclusion

MSI R6870 Temperatures

It's hard to know exactly when the first video card got overclocked, and by whom. What we do know is that it's hard to imagine a computer enthusiast or gamer today that doesn't overclock their hardware. Of course, not every video card has the head room. Some products run so hot that they can't suffer any higher temperatures than they generate straight from the factory. This is why we measure the operating temperature of the video card products we test.

To begin testing, I use GPU-Z to measure the temperature at idle as reported by the GPU. Next I use FurMark 1.8.2 to generate maximum thermal load and record GPU temperatures at high-power 3D mode. The ambient room temperature remained stable at 23C throughout testing. I was lucky to have some nice weather during testing, since my testing is done in an upstairs room that doesn't get as much of the central A/C as I would like. I do have a ton of airflow into the video card section of my benchmarking case, with a 200mm side fan blowing directly inward, so that helps alleviate any high ambient temps.

The MSI R6870 video card recorded 36C in idle mode, and increased to 72C after 30 minutes of stability testing in full 3D mode, at 1920x1200 resolution, and the maximum MSAA setting of 8X. With the fan set on Automatic, the speed only rose to 31% under full load. That was such a low fan speed and a high temperature, that I immediately did a run with manual fan control and 100% fan speed. I was rewarded by the noise of a hair dryer and a greatly reduced load temperature of 54C.

Load

Fan Speed

GPU Temperature

Idle

21% - AUTO (1011 RPM)

36C

Furmark

31% - AUTO (1870 RPM)

72C

Furmark

100% - Manual (4475 RPM)

54C

72C is not a very good result for temperature stress testing, in my opinion. I've become used to seeing video card manufacturers keeping the fan speeds low, especially with the type of radial blower wheel that this reference design uses. In this case, the fan controller barely ramped up from the idle speed of 21% to the 31% mark when running at full load on auto. Obviously, AMD is trying to minimize normal operating noise while retaining a lot of headroom in case things go south inside the PC case. There is definitely some thermal benefit to running the fan harder, as you can see from the 100% fan results above, but the noise is overbearing at full tilt. I expect a lot of users will make use of custom software profiles to control the fan on their HD6870 reference design.

For me, this type of fan noise is more irritating than what an axial fan produces, so I understand why AMD is trying to keep the fan speed down as low as possible. I prefer a video card that pushes all the heated air out the back of the case, and that almost forces the use of the radial blower, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised by the noise performance of this cooling design.

MSi_R6870_Radeon_Video_Card_furmark_temp.jpg

Load temps got up to 69C when running continuous gaming benchmarks with automatic fan speeds, ramping up to 30% with the most challenging titles. This is closer to stress-test-maximum than any other card I've tested, which tells me that this is the operating temperature range that AMD has selected for this GPU. It's higher than I like to see, and I don't think it bodes well for overclocking, but ultimately AMD gets to pick the operating point. I think this also explains why they used such a thick block of copper on the GPU heatsink. That gives the cooling system the ability to absorb and dampen out temperature spikes far better than a design that uses a thin layer of copper to transfer the heat to the heatpipes and aluminum fins.

FurMark is an OpenGL benchmark that heavily stresses and overheats the graphics card with fur rendering. The benchmark offers several options allowing the user to tweak the rendering: fullscreen / windowed mode, MSAA selection, window size, duration. The benchmark also includes a GPU Burner mode (stability test). FurMark requires an OpenGL 2.0 compliant graphics card with lot of GPU power!

MSI_R6870_Video_Card_Furmark_Start_Screen

FurMark does do two things extremely well: drive the thermal output of any graphics processor higher than any other application or video game, and it does so with consistency every time. While FurMark is not a true benchmark tool for comparing different video cards, it still works well to compare one product against itself using different drivers or clock speeds, or testing the stability of a GPU, as it raises the temperatures higher than any program. But in the end, it's a rather limited tool.

In our next section, we discuss electrical power consumption and learn how well (or poorly) each video card will impact your utility bill...



 

Comments 

 
# comentarioalcides juan 2010-11-04 21:13
ya adquiri una placa de video athis muy buena placa gracias por mantenerme informado me gustan mucho los productos que me muestran, gracias
Report Comment
 
 
# You're welcome!Olin Coles 2010-11-04 21:42
Me alegro de que podría ayudarle a hacer una compra informada.
Report Comment
 
 
# ThanksRealNeil 2010-11-05 06:30
Good review. My time for buying parts and building my next system is fast approaching and it will probably have to do me, for a long time. Reviews are what help us to make smarter decisions when we spend our money. While the cost of two GTX460's is not resoundingly expensive for most, it represents a lot for me. (I'm on a disabled Pension) I didn't want to buy the 1GB GTX460 pair of cards without knowing more about the latest ATI offerings. With your help I feel that I can make a final decision now and not blow it. I appreciate it too.
Report Comment
 
 
# Impressive.Crazy 2010-11-29 22:31
Great Review! Thanks so much. I'v been doing some research for my next big build and I really needed to find a graphics card that fit my needs and this is wonderful especially considering the price. Although I do wish it had more for the voltage controls.
Now I just have to decide whether to go with this or wait until the Caymans come out. They just got pushed back again tho... from end of November to mid December. =/

Once again, Great review!!! Really in depth and exactly what I was looking for.

-Crazy
Report Comment
 

Comments have been disabled by the administrator.

Search Benchmark Reviews
QNAP Network Storage Servers

Follow Benchmark Reviews on FacebookReceive Tweets from Benchmark Reviews on Twitter