Archive Home arrow Reviews: arrow Video Cards arrow ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video Card
ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video Card E-mail
Reviews - Featured Reviews: Video Cards
Written by Bruce Normann   
Thursday, 04 February 2010
Table of Contents: Page Index
ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video Card
Radeon HD5450 Features
Radeon HD5450 Specifications
Closer Look: Radeon HD 5450
Radeon HD5450 Detailed Features
ATI Eyefinity Multi-Monitors
Video Card Testing Methodology
3DMark Vantage Benchmarks
Crysis Benchmark Results
Devil May Cry 4 Benchmark
Far Cry 2 Benchmarks
Resident Evil 5 Benchmarks
ATI Radeon HD5450 Temperature
VGA Power Consumption
Radeon HD5450 Final Thoughts
ATI Radeon HD5450 Conclusion

Radeon HD5450 Detailed Features

The big news about the HD5450 is the reduced size of the GPU die. Once again, the newest member of the HD5xxx family has roughly half the number of transistors as the previous one. The chip in the HD5450 is codenamed "Cedar", and has approximately 292 million transistors on it, compared to 627 million on the Redwood chip, which was released last month with the HD5670. The small size is critical to the cost strategy that ATI is pursuing with all these new releases. After some very lean years, struggling to make it in the graphics chip industry, it appears ATI has finally figured out how to make money.

The Cedar die packaging on the HD5450 GPU is a little bigger than half of the Redwood, because the number of interconnects is roughly the same, with the notable exception of the memory interface, which is 64 bits wide this time. The number of Stream Processors has been radically reduced, from 400 down to 80; only 20% of the number present on the Redwood chips. It's evident there are a lot of transistors consumed in the other functions of the GPU, besides shaders.

ATI_RADEON_HD5450_VIDEO_CARD_Cedar_Die_Dime_02.jpg

The memory specification is going to be somewhat flexible for the HD54xx products. I expect most units will be sold with 512MB of GDDR3, but GDDR2 is a possibility, perhaps for OEM variants. 1 GB versions will also be available, although it may be tough to make the case for any performance advantage to be had with that configuration, with the exception of Eyefinity usage. As mentioned above, the GPU-memory interface is 64 bits wide with a maximum bandwidth of 12.8 GB/s, using GDDR3. That's a major hit, compared to the HD5670, with 64GB/s of bandwidth, but I suspect it's well balanced by the greatly reduced number of Stream Processors.

ATI_RADEON_HD5450_VIDEO_CARD_SAMSUNG_Memory_Chip.jpg

The K4W1G1646E-HC11 GDDR3 memory chips are sourced from Samsung. They are rated for a maximum clock rate of 900 MHz, and the marketing specs for the card indicate a maximum clock rate of 800 MHz. Version 0.3.8 of GPU-Z reported that the memory on my sample unit was running at 900 MHz. That's engineering samples for you.... I was suspicious that the clock rate is not being reported correctly in GPU-Z, since it has not been updated to support this new chip yet, but ATI confirmed that they had been building some "extra curricular" prototypes for testing, and some of them got into reviewer's hands. Oh well; their loss and my gain, I guess. Too bad they didn't send me some 1 GHz parts, as they are available from Samsung, according to the product specs shown here below.

ATI_RADEON_HD5450_VIDEO_CARD_samsung_memory_specs.png

The power section of the HD5450 video card is simplistic, and optimized for both cost and low power. In this case, all of the dynamic performance scaling is built into the GPU, and the voltage regulators just ride along. I was observing the shader and memory clocks in GPU-Z while using the PC for normal office-type duties, and this card ramped the clocks up and down faster and more dramatically than any card I've used recently. That's where the power savings are going to be made with this card, getting it down very quickly to idle power, which is a miserly 6.4 watts.

Looking at the business end of the passive cooling, I found something that made my mechanical engineering heart shiver. That little square platform, located between the four threaded standoffs, is created by cutting away all the aluminum around it with a milling machine. Then the platform itself is milled to create the flat, smooth surface we all know is essential for good heat transfer from the mirror surface of the GPU. The word you should be thinking is, "Expensive". I'm pretty sure that the way the GPU chip is mounted on the board makes this expensive manufacturing step essential, and I'm also sure that somewhere there are a couple electronics packaging engineers delivering some serious noogies to the PC Board designer that made all this necessary.

ATI_RADEON_HD5450_VIDEO_CARD_Heatsink_Milled_Face.jpg

The assembly quality is quite good, for an engineering sample. The heat sink had a bit of a gouge in it, but it was put there before the part was anodized, so it doesn't stick out too much. The soldering and surface mount component placement was reasonably well done, and the overall board layout was well designed, with a rational flow.

ATI_RADEON_HD5450_VIDEO_CARD_Assembly_Q_PWR.jpg

Before we dive into the testing portion of the review, let's look at one of the most exciting new features available on every Radeon HD5xxx series product, Eyefinity.



 

Comments 

 
# CompitableBhavesh Patel 2011-10-20 20:09
is ATI Radeon HD5450 compitable with intel dual core 2.8 Ghz processor ?
Please reply as early as possible
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: CompitableOlin Coles 2011-10-20 21:17
Yes. All video cards are compatible with all processors. Just make sure the motherboard has a PCI-Express graphics slot.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video Cardmahmod 2012-03-08 07:50
how to make sure the mother board has a pci-slot?
Report Comment
 
 
# Open up the box and look inside.Bruce 2012-03-08 08:29
Wikipedia has some good pictures on the PCI Express page that show what they look like
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video CardHanzyy 2012-04-24 07:43
Is is good foor games?Will it play them fast? I don't know so much about hardware and stuff...
Report Comment
 
 
# Not so muchBruce 2012-04-24 07:50
This card is on the low end of discrete graphics.
It's really better suited to a Home Theater PC.
Report Comment
 
 
# Fan connectorRoger 2012-06-01 17:01
I see there is what looks like a fan connector on the card - is this correct and if so what would be the power specs for a fan?
Report Comment
 
 
# YesBruce 2012-06-02 11:12
If you look at some of the other HD 5450 cards out on the market (Newegg has 34 models for sale, 2+ years after launch...!) you wll see that many of them have active cooling, with a fan plugged into this very same header. It's only two pins, so don't expect PWM or anything, just straight DC with no speed monitoring.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Fan connectorTaimur 2013-02-05 10:52
The PCI slot has to have the little gap thing, the oppisite way around that does the graphics card have so for instance -- ---- and ---- -- and most of all if the the ports on the graphics card are pointing toward the outside, etc.
Report Comment
 
 
# Re Fan ConnectorRoger 2012-06-02 18:10
Thanks for that Bruce,

Just to clarify such a connected fan would be of similar size and watts etc. to an inbuilt one?

Like I have a spare fan DC 12v 0.11A which is probably ok and another which is DC 12v 0.70A which is probably too powerful?
Report Comment
 
 
# Yes, again....Bruce 2012-06-03 06:58
That's the idea. It's not going to be an exact science, but most fans that are small enough and thin enough to fit on that card's heatsink will be fine. I've been assuming that you want to cool the GPU on the HD 5450 with this fan... right?
Report Comment
 
 
# Thats right Bruce...Roger 2012-06-03 22:01
I figure one cannot have enough fans (especially where I live in the tropics) so I might as well use a spare fan to play on the heatsink. The card will be on the bottom of the mobo with the heat sink facing down so I will mount the fan on the case bottom facing up to the heatsink.

Thanks again
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: ATI Radeon HD5450 HTPC Video Cardjex2013 2013-03-05 18:43
I badly needed an htpc graphic card for my htpc. I am really having a hard time choosing because i really don't have any idea with these kind of things. But anyways, you're post is quite helpful. Thanks!
Report Comment
 
 
# REPLY PLZZZAMINLRB 2013-03-08 13:33
IS THIS CARD GOOD FOR HIGH RESOLUTIO GAMED
REPLY SOOOOON PLEASE
Report Comment
 
 
# No, It's NotBruce 2013-03-08 14:02
It is not good for high resolution games.
It was designed for HTPC use, which is much less demanding.
Plus, it was released three years ago, that's a LONG time in video card history. Why are you interested in it now? Can you even buy one in your location?
Report Comment
 

Comments have been disabled by the administrator.

Search Benchmark Reviews
QNAP Network Storage Servers

Follow Benchmark Reviews on FacebookReceive Tweets from Benchmark Reviews on Twitter