Archive Home arrow Guides arrow Best Thermal Paste Application Methods
Best Thermal Paste Application Methods E-mail
Articles - Featured Guides
Written by Olin Coles   
Monday, 21 April 2008
Table of Contents: Page Index
Best Thermal Paste Application Methods
Mounting Pressure and Finish
Thermally Conductive Element Reference
Application on Round-base Coolers
Application on Square-base Coolers
Application on HDT Coolers

Application on HDT Coolers

Heat-pipe Direct Touch coolers have taken the market by storm. In our recent Best CPU Cooler Performance - Q1 2008 article, all of the top-placed products were built from HDT technology. The excellent concept performs very well in practice - but it's far from perfect.

There are two flaws in the HDT design currently used in CPU cooler products:

  1. The surface is rough and occasionally uneven.
  2. There are channels created between the mounting base and heat-pipe.

Fixing the first problem required some wet-sand paper and elbow grease (that's a metaphor for hard work, so don't go searching the web for another product). By lapping down the surface to a flat even base, you can then polish it down to minimize the grain-like finish inherent of HDT products.

HDT_TIM_Application_Pipe_Fill.jpg

Solving the second problem can be done with potentially less time. Assuming you're not so hard-core that brazing the heat-pipe and mounting base surface gaps together with tin solder is an option, then I would recommend filling the inner channels with thermal paste as pictured above. I have used a black permanent marker to show where the corners of the CPU contact the coolers surface, so use this as a guide for your own application.

As previously mentioned, it's best to avoid oxidizing "white-grease" type TIM's, since they can tarnish the copper surface and bleed out. So with a more solid compound, pack the channels level so that your thermal paste doesn't fill them when the unit is compressed. I didn't bother to fill the outside channels, because the CPU doesn't come in contact with them.

HDT_TIM_Application_Center_Drop.jpg

Using a single drop of material resulted in a spread pattern remarkably similar to that of the single line method for square mounting bases in the previous section. The alloy mounting base creates channels which dramatically limits the depth of material spread over the surface. For this reason alone, HDT coolers must not be treated the same way as other traditional cooler surfaces.

HDT_TIM_Application_Center_Drop_Spread.jpg

Since the single drop pattern pushed most of the material over to the two forward sides, perhaps two drops spaced out roughly 1/3 the width of the processor would prove more successful.

HDT_TIM_Application_Two_Drops.jpg

Once the HDT cooler was lifted from the processor, I was humored by what looked like a pair of "kissing lips". Needless to say, the two drops of material did a much better job of covering the surface, it didn't reach the to the corners very well.

HDT_TIM_Application_Two_Drops_Spread.jpg

Thus far, I have learned that channels created by the heat-pipe rods being pressed into the mounting base pose a serious problem for thermal paste spread. To compensate, the two drop method proved that separating the material will offer good coverage over the directional surface.

HDT_TIM_Application_Two_Lines.jpg

For my final application method, two short lines measuring half the total length of the processor were placed on the two center mounting base partitions. Keep in mind that for this method, as well as the others, it is important to fill the channels level with thermal compound so that the the additional material may spread somewhat unrestricted to the edges.

HDT_TIM_Application_Two_Lines_Spread.jpg

It looks to me like HDT coolers have the uncanny ability to perform well using an unorthodox design, but they also require an equally unique method for properly applying thermal paste to the surface.

This guide wasn't created to become a set of rules to be cast in stone, but rather a collection of methods which I personally tested to help assist you with your own project. As with anything, the results are relevant to the product and methods used. Use these methods as a starting point, and make your own refinements from there to achieve the best performance possible.

Once you've mastered the art of thermal paste application, it's time to search out the best cooler for your project. Benchmark Reviews constantly tests the Best CPU Cooler Performance and offers perspective on the products worth your time and money.

Benchmark Reviews invites you to share your comments and suggestions for this topic in our Discussion Forum.


Related Articles:


 

Comments 

 
# ChampMark 2010-08-12 22:20
Thanks for this mate. It's made installing HDT coolers much easier for me.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Best Thermal Paste Application MethodsJay 2010-09-30 06:09
Thanks Benchmarkreviews for this is a very informative article.
This kind of quality reviews makes it a lot easier for enthusiasts, like me, which do not have much resources for us to try such tests.
Thanks again... and i hope for more quality reviews from you guys..
Report Comment
 
 
# Thanks for your work!Wilson 2010-10-31 12:09
Thank you for researching and publishing your work on applying thermal paste. I don't have a HDT heat sink, but the design is exactly the same as the Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus Direct (blah blah the name is sooooo long).

Thanks Again!
Report Comment
 
 
# Excellent Article!Twisted 2010-11-02 20:15
Thank you for a well written and presented article. I recently purchased a Xigmatek 'Red Scorpion' cooler to replace my stock Intel LGA775 cooler. Now I know how to best apply the paste! Also, my Red Scorpion was supplied with the white thermal paste, thanks again for explaining what these compounds are made from. I will throw out the white paste and get some that has a high silver content.
Cheers!
Report Comment
 
 
# ExcellentMohammad 2010-12-01 20:15
Very well done. Just today I took apart a 212+ and noticed the truly pathetic contact I'd achieved using the Arctic Silver-recommended 'single line' method.

Definitely going this route next time.
Report Comment
 
 
# Heatpipe Directional OrientationJim 2010-12-28 20:13
Olin, under the section "Heatpipe Directional Orientation" are you stating that it is better for the CPU cooling fan to point toward the top of the case, rather than front to back? I would think this would be true for PC cases that have the PSU mounted on the bottom of the case, and have a fan at the top, blowing outward. The new Lian Li PC-A04 case is a perfect example of this. Can you comment? (Thanks!) Perhaps a picture would be helpful here.
Report Comment
 
 
# CorrectionJim 2010-12-28 20:28
In further reading, I realize that I didn't catch what you were explaning. I do understand what you are saying now. But my additional point/question is still relevant. If you take a look at the Lian Li PC-A04 case, wouldn't it make sense to re-orient the CPU cooler towards the top of the case? (They actually do not include a rear fan.) I would think that a vertical orientation of the heat pipes, along with a bottom to top fan direction would be optimal, considering that hot air rises.
Report Comment
 
 
# CorrectionJim 2010-12-30 10:45
Correction: I would think that a horizontal orientation of the heat pipes, along with a bottom to top fan direction would be optimal, considering that hot air rises.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: CorrectionOlin Coles 2011-01-01 10:05
As you've stated, heat rises. Additionally, despite capillary action gravity still affects the heat-pipe fluid. It's best to orientate the heatsink so that heat-pipes are either level or collecting fluid at the base.
Report Comment
 
 
# EarthwormJimEarthworm Jim 2011-03-29 15:15
Assuming that "BB" size is equal to 4,57 mm and "BBB" to 4,83, and as "LGA775" is 37,5 x 37,5 millimetres, and on the picture with the peas the pea is approximately 1/3rd of the diameter which results in 12,5 mm. which is 1,25 cm I do arrive to the conclusion that in you country agronomy is really advanced. In my country peas are generally around half a centimetre, which make them BBB size and almost BB size. So, in conclusion, the community
is still as keen as it thought, or in other words, it is not mistaken - your peas are mistaken ( they are really f***** up ;) ). I do hope this is cleared out, and I do hope that somebody confirms the size of the peas on the picture, based on my assumptions!
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: EarthwormJimOlin Coles 2011-03-29 15:31
These were frozen peas, and they are slightly larger than a pencil eraser. In the photo, that bit of thermal paste was roughly half the mass of a BB, and it covered the entire contact base on an old LGA775 cooler.
Report Comment
 
 
# Peas and such...StressLess 2011-08-13 16:52
The peas being referred to by the term "the size of a pea" (and in the fable "The Princess and the Pea") are the peas you make pea soup out of, which are dried peas. Dried peas are much smaller than frozen peas, about the size of the TIM you used in the now infamous frozen peas picture. But instead of peas, I had heard the amount to place was the size of a rice grain which also works and is less confusing.

On a different subject, I would liked to have seen the results of mounting the square cooler that you did a thin, even spread of TIM on. How did it look when removed?

Also I would like to see heat readings from all these different application methods. While you may want one or the other spreads visually, how does that translate into actual practice? Could less coverage translate into a thinner layer that increases metal to metal contact, yielding better results than 100% CPU coverage but thicker layer? Inquiring minds want to know!!
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Best Thermal Paste Application MethodsEarthworm Jim 2011-03-29 15:16
Still, thanks for the knowledge!
Report Comment
 
 
# Hyper 212#3 2011-04-13 17:38
When using the line method with the thermal 212+ would I need two lines or three (since it has 4 copper pipes?
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Hyper 212Olin Coles 2011-04-13 17:43
Three. The number shall be three.
Report Comment
 
 
# Meaning of the following statementMohan 2011-07-28 00:22
"it is important to fill the channels level with thermal compound so that the the additional material may spread somewhat unrestricted to the edges"

now what is 'channels level' we are talking about here?
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Best Thermal Paste Application MethodsMoto Psycho 2011-07-28 07:09
^Where you have pipes on the heatsink base, there are tiny dips as the surfaces meet, the base is not 100% flat, therefore it is vital that you ensure these channels are filled with paste to properly conduct the heat away from the processor
Moto
Report Comment
 
 
# hands claplacky 2011-08-14 20:39
thanks for that. great job.
Report Comment
 
 
# Deep HDT pipes?Traveller 2011-09-04 11:15
Hi Olin. I found your article to be extremely informative, thanks. I was wondering if you could shed some further light on whether or not failure to sand down an HDT cooler would make any significant difference for a pc that is never going to be overclocked at all. I would particularly appreciate your views on the Coolermaster Hyper TX3 cooler, which looks as if the the pipes are set too deep into the mounting base. See links below.

##overclockersclub.com/vimages/coolermaster_hyper_t x3/8.jpg
##goldfries.com/images/hwreviews/2010/coolermasterhypertx3/cmhypertx3_04.jpg

After having read your article, I have concluded that the two drops on the two centre partitions of the mounting base would be the best option for the Hyper TX3 cooler (to be used with an AMD Phenom II x6 1100T CPU), however, if sanding is not carried out, how would one deal with the space between the deeply set pipes and the CPU surface? Also, I have read that even merely touching the metal with a finger can cause grease and all kinds of particles to become stuck to it, so if sanding were to be carried out, how could one possible ensure that the cooler is thoroughly cleaned of all the residue from sanding? Thank you for any advice.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Deep HDT pipes?Olin Coles 2011-09-04 12:00
Why would you ever sand/lap the surface of a CPU/heatsink that isn't going to be heavily overclocked? Almost any aftermarket cooler can handle stock voltage loads.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Deep HDT pipes?Traveller 2011-09-05 06:54
Ok Olin, thank you for clearing that up. I'm new to all of this and didn't know if the sanding was recommended for 'normal' use or not.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: RE: Deep HDT pipes?Olin Coles 2011-09-05 10:31
Just use a thin amount of thermal paste over the CPU, and make sure to mount the heatsink as firmly as possible. This alone will give you more cooling performance than required.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Deep HDT pipes?Traveller 2011-09-05 11:24
Is that in addition to the two drops on the two centre partitions of the cooler or only on the CPU? In either case, shouldn't I still be filling the channels on the cooler base? Thanks.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: RE: Deep HDT pipes?Olin Coles 2011-09-05 11:44
You can apply two drops, or you can use a clean finger to spread a very light film over the top of the CPU. I prefer to apply a thin film.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: Deep HDT pipes?Traveller 2011-09-06 06:47
Ok thanks for the advice, Olin.
Report Comment
 

Comments have been disabled by the administrator.

Search Benchmark Reviews
QNAP Network Storage Servers

Follow Benchmark Reviews on FacebookReceive Tweets from Benchmark Reviews on Twitter