Archive Home arrow Reviews: arrow Network arrow NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE Switch
NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE Switch E-mail
Reviews - Featured Reviews: Network
Written by Bruce Normann   
Monday, 29 April 2013
Table of Contents: Page Index
NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE Switch
Closer Look: NETGEAR XS708E
Detailed Features
Technology Details
Features and Specifications
ProSAFE Plus Switch Setup
Network Management Settings
Network Switch Testing Methodology
TestResults
Final Thoughts
Conclusion

NETGEAR XS708E ProSAFE Plus
10GbE Switch Review

Manufacturer: NETGEAR, Inc.
Model Number: XS708E-100NES
UPC: 606449090550
Price As Tested: $936.99 (NewEgg | Amazon)

Full Disclosure: The product sample used in this article has been supplied by NETGEAR.

The first public cell phone call was placed on April 3rd 1973 by Marty Cooper, who championed the development of the first truly portable device while he was with Motorola. Something else happened that same year which has arguably had the same level of impact on society. Ethernet is also 40 years old this year (2013) and has established itself in almost every facet of our digital lives. Like many ubiquitous elements of modern consumer technology, it was developed at XEROX PARC (Palo Alto Research Center) and then commercialized elsewhere. Ethernet came to the PC in 1982, with inexpensive twisted-pair network cabling as a bonus, and the rest is history. The original bandwidth cap was 10 Megabits per second, the current top spec is 100 Gigabits per second, and the IEEE 802.3 Ethernet Study Group is currently finalizing the standards for 400 Gb/s. Most consumers and small businesses are operating at single GbE speeds (1Gb/s), but that will change in the next few years to 10GbE, based on trends I'm seeing in the market. The server market is already there, it's just a question of when the consumer product lines adopt the latest NIC-on-a-chip solutions from the major suppliers. The next piece in the puzzle is 10GbE switches and routers to link the networks together.

Network switches are not reviewed by the press that often, but they are a necessary part of many home or small business networks, so we need to be aware of what's available and what works well. NETGEAR is a long-established player in the networking market, and they have many different product lines to choose from. Today, Benchmark Reviews is looking the NETGEAR XS708E, a break-out offering in their ProSAFE Plus Switch line that brings eight ports of 10GbE connectivity down to the masses. 10GbE switches are a critical part of the infrastructure that needs to be in place before adoption of this faster networking standard can spread.

L_FR_34_Full_01.jpg

First, let's clarify what a network switch is. It is strictly a wired device, and is most often designed to switch Ethernet traffic. There are telco switches, and video switchers, and fiber optic switches, but the vast majority of network switches you and I will encounter handle Ethernet. In Wireless networks, routers and adapters generally communicate directly with one another, but wireless media bridges are starting to make that distinction a little fuzzy. You could use the couple of ports on the back of your router to connect a few devices together, but switches still have some advantages:

  • Switches allow dozens of devices to connect
  • Switches keep traffic between two devices from getting in the way of your other devices using the same network
  • Switches allow control of who has access to various parts of the network
  • Switches allow you to monitor usage
  • High-end switches have pluggable modules to tailor them to network needs

Until recently, there were only two types of switches, un-managed and managed. The first type is truly plug-and-play, there are no settings to make, no configurations to set, and they always work the same way, for every device plugged into one of its ports. This was the only kind of switch available to the average consumer, and they served their purpose well. The managed switches were strictly for the corporate LANs and data centers. They were configured by the high holy priests of corporate IT, called "LAN Administrators". No one could make a change in the network unless they logged into one or more switches and made it, usually with cryptic command-line instructions. Nowadays, they can log in to a GUI via a web browser, but I know some of them still use command line arguments.

Today, there are some new classes of switches sandwiched between these two extremes. The most common type is usually called a "Smart Switch". It has a number of features that come straight from the managed switch play book, and is targeted to both corporate users and what the industry politely calls "ProSumers". That's you and me, in case you didn't recognize your new title. The NETGEAR GS110T that was featured in a recent Benchmark Reviews article is a good example of a Smart Switch. The XS708E we are investigating today is part of the ProSAFE Plus line, with a feature set somewhere between the unmanaged and Smart Switch products. The Plus line management tools include VLAN support, QoS, IGMP snooping, port trunking, rate limiting, and traffic monitoring. That's enough for most SMB users, especially those who are willing to trade some high-end features for pure speed.

The XS708E is the lowest cost model in the new NETGEAR family of ProSAFE Plus 10GbE Switches. It's got eight 100/1000/10000 Mbps RJ45 ports, with one combo port supporting 10 Gigabit speed on an SFP+ connector. This type of port is commonly used to support fiber optic cables, but lower cost direct-connect copper cables are available for short haul applications. For now, the most likely application of the XS708E is simple and affordable 10GE connectivity for 10G-capable servers and storage devices employed by smaller organizations. If you've followed some of my NAS reviews, it should come as no surprise that the first thing I did after I powered up the XS708E, was to connect it to one of the 10GbE capable NAS models on my test bench. The sense of relief was palpable - THAT'S the way a NAS ought to run...

Let's take a closer look at the XS708E, and see what it offers in both features and performance.



 

Comments 

 
# Try PCATTCPDave 2013-04-30 13:23
I ran into the exact same problem testing some Emulex 10GbE NIC/iSCSI adapters and our Cisco Nexus 5000 series 10GbE switches. In order to verify full 10GbE, I used PCATTCP in a client/server config to stress the network. I was able to get full 10GbE (~1200MBytes/sec each way, ~2400+MBytes/sec total) using this tool.

You need to increase the buffers to 256K from 8K to get it to saturate the link.

Google PCATTCP to get the software (runs in Windows, tested on 2K8 and 2K3).

Here's the CLI argumetns for the server I used:

C:\> pcattcp -r -c -l 262144 -A 0

And here's the CLI arguments for the client

C:\> pcattcp -t - l 262144 -A 0 -c -D server_IP

Note: The only way I got full line rate was to make sure TOE (TCP Offload Engine) was running, and that RSS (recieve-side-scaling) was on to distribute the load across cores.

Oh, and I also discovered that not all 10GbE Copper SFP+ cables are made equal =) The first two sets were flaky, the third provided solid throughput.

-Dave
Report Comment
 
 
# Good Info...!Bruce Normann 2013-04-30 13:39
Thanks Dave,

This is all bleeding edge at the moment, so I appreciate you sharing.
Our readers are the BEST!
I'll definitely look into that PCATTCP software.
Report Comment
 
 
# If you run into complications...Dave 2013-04-30 18:15
Let me know, I might be able to assist. 10GbE can be tricky and it starts to push the limits of what TCP can handle. Some of the defaults used by older OS's for TCP were fine with 100Mbit and 1Gbit, but start to hold back 10GbE (hence the buffer window increase to 256K with PCATTCP).

If you can't get the 10GbE link up to full rate, try using multiple clients against a single server (you can run pcattcp multiple times with different ports).

-Dave
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE SwitchRichard Wyattt 2013-05-19 00:33
Newegg is really overpriced on this switch
Report Comment
 
 
# CheaperFernando 2013-05-31 16:34
Correct, Newegg super overpriced this puppy. If you look around you can find for $840 or lower. Soon it will be $799 and lower.
Report Comment
 
 
# may be pci-e to power system ?jean-christophe geny 2013-06-14 00:00
the box is clean but the power system looks heavy .
today i should received a platinum psu i paid 320 euros : Corsair AX1200i 80PLUS Platinum , mostly because it has seven years warranty i selected platinum , mostly because it has an usb connector to check its health had made me take this one.

i am sure these kind of psu could power 6 to 8 of these boards using the pci-e 6 or 8 cables plugs and the main pc of the network having a cpu or two and at least one or more 10 Gb link that are not used to have great vga card .
so board could get down to nearly half of the current price .

can you check that #benchmarkreviews.com ?
Report Comment
 
 
# DC Power in data CentersBruce Bruce 2013-06-14 13:06
Jean-Cristophe, what you are describing (I think...) is not a very common power distribution architecture. I agree that it is wasteful to have a 150W PSU for a component that uses only half of the available power. Some data centers are using centrallized DC power supplies, that push 24VDC out to the racks. In that case, you can eliminate the PSU inside the component, which reduces heat generation within the rack and allows tighter spacing. This arangement is very specialled though, and the reason it's done is not to reduce capital cost, but to reduce operating costs. In that regards, your 80 Plus Platinum rated PSU is a step in that direction, i.e. you've got a large, very efficient PSU, why not use it?

As far as reducing cost goes, the PSU in this switch doesnt contribute very much to the BOM cost. Like most leading edge technology products, it's the latest, greatest chips buried deep inside that are the main cost component.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE SwitchRon 2013-06-14 01:01
Ethernet is also 40 years old this year (2013)
The idea was documented in a memo in 1973. Experiments run 3 years later at PARC ran at only 2.94Mbps.

PC in 1982, with inexpensive twisted-pair network cabling as a bonus

10base5 "Thicknet" was the medium in 1982. 10baseT didn't become popular until the 1990s.
Report Comment
 
 
# RE: NETGEAR XS708E ProSafe Plus 10GbE SwitchRon 2013-06-14 01:28
There's a noticeable amount of cut-and-paste from the NETGEAR GS110T.
Report Comment
 

Comments have been disabled by the administrator.

Search Benchmark Reviews
QNAP Network Storage Servers

Follow Benchmark Reviews on FacebookReceive Tweets from Benchmark Reviews on Twitter